Parliamentary question by Marco Pannella (NI) and Maurizio Turco (NI) to the Commission and answer given by Mr Patten on behalf of the Commission
WRITTEN QUESTION E-0673/03
by Marco Pannella (NI) and Maurizio Turco (NI) to the Commission
(26 February 2003)
Subject: Serious and persistent violation of religious freedom by the Russian authorities
On 21 February this year Bronislav Czaplicki, a Polish Catholic priest working in Pushkin, a town near St Petersburg, was asked by the Russian authorities to leave the country because his residence permit had been withdrawn.
This is the latest in a series of moves on the part of the Russian authorities to expel ministers of religion. The following are examples from 2002:
- in September Leo Martensson, a Swedish Evangelical minister working in the Krasnodar area, had his residence permit withdrawn; on 12 September Jaroslaw Wisniewski, a Polish Catholic minister working in the Sakhalin area, was stopped on his arrival in Khabarovsk (in the far east of Russia) and deported to Japan, from where he had arrived by air; on 10 September the residence permit of Eduard Mackiewicz, a Polish Catholic working in the Rostov-on-Don area, was withdrawn;
- in August Stanislav Krajnak, a Slovakian Catholic working in the Yaroslavl area, was refused a residence permit; Chalyshan Seidi, a Turkish Muslim working in the Bashkortostan area, was expelled; Victor Barousse, an American Pentecostal minister working in the Irkutsk area, was refused a residence permit;
- in June the residence permit of Aleksei Ledyayev, a Lithuanian Pentecostal minister was withdrawn; Ronald Cook, Virginia Cook and Jeffrey, Susan and Jordan Wollman, American Evangelicals working in the Kostroma area, were refused residence permits; the 14th Dalai Lama Tenzin Gyatso, a Tibetan refugee, was refused a visa;
- on 19 April the residence permit of Monsignor Jerzy Mazur, a Polish Catholic bishop in the diocese of San Giuseppe in Irkutsk (southern Siberia), was withdrawn; on 15 April the residence permit of Don Stefano Caprio, an Italian Catholic working in the Vladimir area, who had been resident in Russia for 12 years, was withdrawn;
- in February the residence permit of Paul Kim, a South Korean Evangelical working in the Kalmykia area, was withdrawn; Autumn Newson, Matthew Crain and Weston Pope, US citizens and Mormons, working in the Pskov area, were expelled.
Can the Commission answer the following questions:
- Does it know about these incidents? What steps has it taken or does it intend to take vis-à-vis the authorities of Russia, a signatory to the International Declaration of Human Rights, which it is seriously and persistently violating by virtue of these actions?
- What steps has it taken or will it take regarding the motion for a resolution signed by 133 MEPs calling for respect for religious freedom to be included among the priorities for action in the EU's relations with third countries and to make provision, in the event of violations, for sanctions similar to those envisaged since 1988 by the US law on religious freedom in the world (Public Law 105-292/105th Congress)?
Answer given by Mr Patten
on behalf of the Commission
(3 April 2003)
The Commission is aware of the refusal to provide and/or withdrawal of residence permits from a number of persons seeking to practice religion in Russia. The Commission is conscious of the difficult situation in which religions other than Russian orthodoxy find themselves in Russia. Indeed, several expulsions have taken place since April 2002, following the decision by the Vatican to seek to upgrade the four temporary church structures in Russia to permanent Roman catholic dioceses. Other churches have also been the target of expulsions.
It is for this reason that the Commission – in the context of Union/Russia political dialogue – has on a number of occasions underlined that the Union/Russia partnership is based on fundamental core values, among which is full respect of human rights.
It is to be recalled that each State enjoys discretion whether to allow for the presence of foreigners within its territory or not. Therefore, in general, a revocation of a residence permit cannot be deemed to be incompatible with the major international and European Human Rights conventions that Russia has ratified. On the other hand, revocation of a residence permit for the sole reason to undermine the exercise of religion or belief might well constitute an indirect sanction contrary to the freedom of religion or belief, depending on the circumstances in each case. The Commission will continue to impress upon the Russian authorities on this issue
In parallel, the promotion of human rights in Russia will continue to be a priority in the framework of the European Initiative for Democracy and Human Rights (EIDHR), Russia being a focus country under this programme.
Iscritti e contribuenti 2014
|Stefano T. Roma||200 €|
|Federico M. Castiglione Delle Stiviere||200 €|
|Bruno G. Roma||15 €|
|Alda B. Follonica||100 €|
|Luca P. Pesaro||200 €|
|Marco Jr. Z. Milano||200 €|
|Valter M. Ancona||590 €|
|Giampaolo M. Pavia||200 €|
|Roberto G.||200 €|
|Marina F. Vicenza||600 €|
|Total SUM||402.713 €|
RussiaTonino Picula, Croatian member of the NRPTT recently headed the short-term observer mission for the Russian election from the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE).
RussiaItalian and Russian democrats letter to Romano Prodi
RussiaOLYMPIAD 2012: SHAME OF MOSCOW 1980 AND BERLIN 1936 SHOULD NOT REPEAT, OLYMPIC GAMES SHOULD NOT PASS IN THE CAPITAL OF BELLIGERENT STATE WITH MASS VIOLATIONS OF HUMAN RIGHTS
RussiaCASE OF SAMODUROV - VASILOVSKAYA - ALCHUK: "TO THE HOLY OFFICE OF PUBLIC PROSECUTOR FOR EXECUTION OF JUSTICE TO HERETICS" - RADICALS BRING BUNDLES OF DRY BRUSHWOOD TO THE BUILDING OF THE OFFICE OF GENERAL PROSECUTOR OF RUSSIA
Dello stesso autore
Letter by Pannella and Turco, sent this morning to the Democratic Party, to its Secretary Renzi, to the President of its Assembly Cuperlo, and to the members of the Secretariat
01/23/2006Procuratorship calls for four years imprisonment for Dmitriyevsky
01/23/2006Publication to support Stanislav Dmitriyevsky
01/23/2006Why Dmitrievsky is in the dock
06/26/2008 Civil Rights QUESTIONS (EP) EP, Write question, Detention-without-charge in the UK
10/01/2007 Chechnya QUESTIONS (EP) OSCE's Exclusion of Nongovernmental Organizations, a Violation of the Helsinki Principles
07/01/2005 QUESTIONS (EP) Vietnam Human rights violations against the Montagnard people of the Vietnam Highlands
03/01/2005 Egypt QUESTIONS (EP) Ayman Nur: Reply to the written question of Emma Bonino by Benita Ferrero-Waldner on behalf of the EC